Oak or pine dining table?
Posted on October 15 2021
Why is oak the best option?
El oak and pine are two of the most used finishes for furniture. However, they don't have much in common. Each has its own pros and cons that will give your home different benefits. Read our guide and you can choose the best finish according to your preferences.
Is oak better than pine?
There is a misconception that oak is better than pine. Both solid woods have their own benefits such as hardness, color, and durability. The choice of one or the other depends on what you need. Oak is long-lasting and pine remains strong and attractive and is a more economical option.
Oak or pine, there are many things to consider when choosing the right furniture finish for your home.
NordicStory Dining table "France",
Soft or hard wood
The main difference to take into account of these two woods is that oak is a hard wood and pine is a soft wood, although it will still be as hard as oak to the touch.
This difference is not noticeable in itself, but it is in the structure of the wood itself. Evergreens (which produce softwood) have a different system for transporting water through the trunk compared to angiosperms (which produce hardwood). This creates a different structure in the wood, which gives it its different properties.
While softwood is still very strong, hardwood is more durable. One of the most popular reasons people choose oak furniture over pine is because oak has a longer lifespan than pine.
They both have a nice grain. Oak trees tend to be more wavy, with more knots and unique markings. It is more defined and noticeable than the grain of pine, because like most hardwoods, it has deeper pores. Pine tends to have straighter grains that are lighter.
This is one of the most frequently discussed properties.
Due to the time it takes for wood to grow and the difference between softwood and hardwood, oak is a naturally more durable material for furniture compared to pine.
This is not to say that pine is a weak option. Pine is extremely tough, but oak is less likely to dent, stain, or wear out over a long period of time compared to pine.
However, this is not to say that oak is the right choice. If you are looking for furniture that will last 50 years or more, then yes, go for oak. But if you are looking for furniture for the bedroom of children, then pine is the best choice. You can replace it as your children grow and redecorate their room. Or get rid of it when your child moves in and their bedroom functions as a different space. Therefore, you may not need your furniture to be as durable.
Regarding the difference in durability there is another factor, the price. You have to consider if the extra shelf life is something you find useful. If so, then the oak is well worth the investment as it will last for a long time.
The price difference between oak and pine is due to the fact that oak takes much longer to grow than pine. If cost is an important factor to you, you may want to opt for pine furniture. It's still sturdy and looks attractive, but it's slightly less durable in the long run and therefore less expensive. However, if cost is not a primary factor, you might consider other properties of oak versus pine to decide which is best for you.
When the wood is not finished or has a natural finish, pine is usually lighter in color than oak, although there are times when certain oaks or species have a very pale wood.
However, the natural color of oak and pine will rarely affect your choice of what material to choose for your furniture, as both woods can have their appearance altered. Different finishes can make the furniture lighter or darker so you can get the look you want.
Can oak and pine be painted?
Yes, both oak and pine furniture can be painted. It is true that painted oak furniture is not uncommon, but pine actually lends itself better to painting. This can be another great reason to choose pine for children's furniture - it can be redecorated years later if you start to get tired or if your child wants a new look in their room.
Pine is usually much lighter than oak due to the density of the wood. Oak, as a hardwood, takes longer to grow and is much denser. This means that it is also much heavier, which affects durability and toughness.
Which is better?
There is no correct answer. If you are looking for a very durable solid wood furniture, and the cost is not a problem, oak will be the best option. If you're looking for less expensive solid wood furniture that will last long enough, but don't mind replacing it eventually, then pine is perfect. If you are decorating a child's bedroom, for example, or looking for a less expensive option for your living room.
Visit our website and come and meet us!